Candy Corn Mystery 

Based on the clues, who do you think is the candy corn thief? Be sure to describe your reasoning here!

The thief cannot be Franque or Elvira, as neither of those play EQ (EQ Is relevant, as it is the game that has a level 82 Cleric..)

Jackie and Vladimer are both also out of the running for thief, as it seems highly unlikely that they would talk about their Pumpkin Pie recipes, when neither likes pumpkin pie.

This leaves Mumsie and Moldie.

It cannot be Mumsie, as the main food listed that has sprinkles is Cupcakes, which she does not like. Leaving the most logical thief to be Moldie.

I voted Elvira. I may have overlooked it but I don't believe it says Elvira doesn't play EQ. When I narrowed down the treats that the suspects liked, Elvira was the only one who liked both pumpkin pie and Cupcakes. Given it doesn't say whether or not she plays EQ1, The best choice for the thief is Elvira to me.

MasterCosmo wrote:

I voted Elvira. I may have overlooked it but I don't believe it says Elvira doesn't play EQ. When I narrowed down the treats that the suspects liked, Elvira was the only one who liked both pumpkin pie and Cupcakes. Given it doesn't say whether or not she plays EQ1, The best choice for the thief is Elvira to me.

 

Yup, Elvira I couldn't ever prove didn't play EQ (except for the fact Girls don't play EQ)... I did prove she liked Pumpkin Pie, and Cupcakes though (2/3 of the criteria). But, it was also provable that Moldie liked Cupcakes and Played eq (again, 2/3)

Whatever suspect is the one that enjoys all the treats is the culprit.

can we get an answer to this?